Why Do Mirrors Seem to Reverse Left and Right?
A mirror reverses depth, not left and right. The Marx Brothers’ Duck Soup turns that distinction into a joke you can try at home.
Raise the hand nearest the door while you face a mirror. The hand you see in the glass is still on the door side of the room. The mirror hasn’t swapped the two sides. What changes is depth: a hand in front of the glass appears the same distance behind it.
Now ask someone to stand opposite you and pretend to be that reflection. If you both raise your right hand, the trick falls apart. Your partner has to raise their left to match your right. In Duck Soup (1933), Harpo Marx has to get that sort of thing exactly right. Then he has to get it wrong in a way that makes you laugh.
This article describes the mirror gag, not the film’s ending.
The hand stays on the door side
Think of the glass as a boundary. Take any point on your raised hand, move straight towards the glass and continue just as far on the other side. That gives you the point’s apparent position in the reflection. To get there, you have changed neither its height nor its position along the glass. Only its distance in front of or behind the glass has changed. The same rule applies to your nose, your cuff and the door behind you. [1]
So why does the reflection look left-handed? We compare it with a person facing us. An ordinary person gets into that position by turning round. During the turn, their right hand moves to the other side of the room. A reflection doesn’t make the turn. It faces us while keeping that hand on the original side. The physics and the apparent change of handedness aren’t competing explanations; they describe the same image using different reference points.
Text makes the difference particularly obvious. If you hold up a transparent sheet with writing on it and then look at it from the other side, it appears backwards. Turning the sheet the other way up won’t make the writing read normally. You have changed which side of the lettering you’re looking from, not rearranged the letters along the sheet.
Two men and no glass
In Leo McCarey’s Duck Soup, Pinky, played by Harpo Marx, breaks a mirror while disguised as Groucho’s Firefly. He takes up a position on the far side of the empty frame and plays the missing reflection. We know where the glass has gone. Firefly has to work that out for himself. [2]
Try watching the men’s distance from the frame instead of their faces. A reflection has to keep pace, but it also has to stand the right distance away. A step towards the glass calls for both men to close in on the frame, each from his own side. A movement along the glass calls for them to go towards the same side of the room. The empty frame lets us judge both distances at once. The comedians have only their own timing to hold it together.
Once we accept that arrangement, they can loosen it. They move past each other through the space where the glass ought to be, yet the routine goes on. The point is no longer whether Firefly will spot a bad reflection. We’re watching two people maintain a fiction that both their bodies have already contradicted. [2]
Try it without the glass
Stand in a doorway with a partner on the other side. Each take one step back. Raise whichever hand is nearer the same doorpost. Next, both take a small step towards that post. Finally, take one step forwards towards each other. The first two actions preserve the position along the doorway; the third makes your distances from its plane shrink together. Try to do each move without counting in.
It’s surprisingly easy to get the hand right and the timing wrong. The mirror at home never has to wait and see what you’ll do. That is the advantage Harpo doesn’t have, and the reason the imitation is worth watching even after you know how the trick works.
Sources
Film technique
For the next unexpected question, follow the Journal in your RSS reader.
From this story
Films discussed
-
Duck Soup
A tiny nation hires Groucho Marx and discovers that government is perfect slapstick.
Explore the film
Want a recommendation shaped around your evening? Ask Momo what to watch next →